@admin

1. Why were such drastic changes implemented without any prior notice? At the very least, a month's notice should have been given to allow users to adapt.
2. What’s the purpose of SmartAPI if it no longer supports order placement via API? It’s disappointing that customer concerns don’t seem to have been raised with the exchange, showing a lack of empathy for your users.

Please confirm if SmartAPI is no longer a solution for API-based execution so we can explore alternative brokers/APIs accordingly.

How can you make this change without advance notice.
A POA filing takes 3-4 working days.

And you are not giving any advance notice but doing this change in next working day itself.

Very unplanned launches and changes done by Angel broking, completely unfriendly for users.

When should we expect this new version of SmartAPIs to be available? I want to add my family member's account to this, but he just opened the account 2 days back. Want to add the account to SmartAPI asap.

@admin

1. Why were such drastic changes implemented without any prior notice? At the very least, a month's notice should have been given to allow users to adapt.
2. What’s the purpose of SmartAPI if it no longer supports order placement via API? It’s disappointing that customer concerns don’t seem to have been raised with the exchange, showing a lack of empathy for your users.

Please confirm if SmartAPI is no longer a solution for API-based execution so we can explore alternative brokers/APIs accordingly.

This happens again and again even on a single API call.

Angel team, are you ever going to resolve this?

Yes, same issue faced multiple times.

Even on sending 1 request in a second, it is giving the error for Holdings API.

This has been happening almost every day when the API is used. Why is the team not fixing this, even after so many users reporting these in multiple posts?

When should we expect this new version of SmartAPIs to be available? I want to add my family member's account to this, but he just opened the account 2 days back. Want to add the account to SmartAPI asap.

@T167171 Invalid Session or Session is Expired Please Re-login.
Happening with rmsLimit() api.

Facing this issue again.
@admin when would this be cleared?

@admin Thank you, working now.

Requesting Angel team to follow quality practices for releases/updates, by:

1. Giving notice in advance on the changes
2. Updating Libraries and not just their internal systems (which was done here eventually after requesting), so that API users can also update on their end.

@admin I don't think this is the best way for users to update the library on their end.
Why can't Angel team update the library version, so that its an online sync that can be done without checking out the smart api repository?

Even if there is any change around including TOTP in the Smartconnect generateSession, the SmartAPI library is not updated by Angel.

The older version was 1.2.9 and even if I reinstall the library now, it still is same. https://github.com/angel-one/smartapi-python

The error I am getting by adding TOTP in the generateSession is:
"TypeError: SmartConnect.generateSession() takes 3 positional arguments but 4 were given"

I have never seen a more irresponsible release plan for any user-facing product.


How can you make this change without advance notice.
A POA filing takes 3-4 working days.

And you are not giving any advance notice but doing this change in next working day itself.

Very unplanned launches and changes done by Angel broking, completely unfriendly for users.